rustio rustio.net

aion_verify vs aion_verify_subject vs tpt-eidos-kernel

Side-by-side comparison of Rust crates

43
aion_verify
experimentalv3.9.0

First-party proof engine, no_std, no unsafe, no external solver. TIER 4 enumerates: it checks a predicate against EVERY input in a bounded/enumerable domain, returning Proven{cases} or Refuted with the counterexample -- complete coverage, not a sample. Combinators: for_all, for_all_where, for_all_u8, for_all_in, for_all_pairs. TIER 5 proves properties over UNBOUNDED integer domains -- all 2^64 values of u64, any number of variables -- WITHOUT enumerating them, by interval abstract interpretation, via an Expr/Prop DSL and prove_contract for pre/postcondition contracts. Tier 5 is SOUND BUT INCOMPLETE: transfer functions over-approximate, so it answers Proven, Refuted with a concrete counterexample, or UNKNOWN when the abstraction is too imprecise (typically relational properties) -- never a false Proven or Refuted. An SMT-based checker such as Kani/CBMC decides cases this returns Unknown on, so Kani remains a stronger independent second opinion rather than being replaced.

48
aion_verify_subject
experimentalv1.0.0

A small, dependency-free access-control domain -- badges, roles, clearances, wings, revocation -- published so that aion_verify's test suite can demonstrate the thing that matters about a proof engine: proving ANOTHER crate's invariants, over the whole of a finite domain, in code that knows nothing about the engine. Not a verification tool; the SUBJECT of one. no_std, no alloc, no unsafe, no dependencies.

47
tpt-eidos-kernel
experimentalv0.2.0

Trusted refinement-subtyping typechecker for tpt-eidos (MVK)

Core Metrics

aion_verifyaion_verify_subjecttpt-eidos-kernel
Health Score434847
Total Downloads28341162
30d Downloads000
Dependents016
Releases1412
Last Updated62d ago62d ago73d ago
Age2m2m2m

Health Breakdown

aion_verify
Maintenance
9
Quality
16
Community
6
Popularity
3
Documentation
9
aion_verify_subject
Maintenance
9
Quality
18
Community
7
Popularity
2
Documentation
12
tpt-eidos-kernel
Maintenance
10
Quality
14
Community
8
Popularity
3
Documentation
12

Technical Details

aion_verifyaion_verify_subjecttpt-eidos-kernel
Version3.9.01.0.00.2.0
Stable (≥1.0)✓ Yes✓ Yes✗ No
LicenseMPL-2.0MPL-2.0Apache-2.0 OR MIT
Dependencies102
Crate Size77KB15KB16KB
Features200
Yanked %7.1%0.0%0.0%
Edition202120212021
MSRV1.811.811.74
Owners111

Quick Verdict

  • •aion_verify_subject leads with a health score of 48/100, but none of the options score above 80.
  • •aion_verify has the most downloads (283), suggesting wider adoption.
  • •tpt-eidos-kernel is pre-1.0 — API may change.